Griddle 101: Answering Your Questions


Hello Friends,

First off, thank you so much for responding to last week’s email. I got right around 200 responses, which honestly blew me away. I’m still working through replying to everyone, so if you haven’t heard back from me yet, you will. I really appreciate you taking the time to write.

Over the next few weeks, I’m going to answer some of the most common questions that came up in your replies. Today I want to hit two of them: cooking steak on the griddle and cooking during the winter.

Steak on the Griddle (Quick Tips)
Here’s a quick breakdown, and I’ll link the full video below if you want to see it step by step.

  • Choose ribeye or New York strip with good marbling, about 1½ inches thick
  • Thicker steaks give you time to build a crust without overcooking
  • Season simply with salt and keep the steak dry
  • Pat dry, salt, rest 30–60 minutes, then pat dry again before cooking
  • Preheat the griddle hot (about 450–500°F) with a high smoke point oil
  • Use light pressure to get good contact, but don’t smash the steak
  • Cook in short stages, flipping to a fresh hot spot each time
  • Finish on lower heat and sauté onions and mushrooms in the drippings
  • Butter, garlic, and herbs are optional but add great flavor
  • Keep it simple, especially if it’s your first time

Cooking on the Griddle in the Winter

Yes, you can cook in the winter. I do it all the time. The key is how you preheat.

  • Always preheat on low, especially in cold weather
  • Don’t crank it to high right away when it’s cold outside
  • Sudden high heat can shock and warp the griddle
  • It will take longer to heat up in 30-degree weather, and that’s fine
  • Be patient and let the griddle come up to temp gradually

Slow preheating is the safest way to protect your griddle and still cook year-round.

I hope this helps, and as always, I appreciate you being here.

video preview

Thanks,
Johnny